Mama Janes Eatery Menu (2025 Update)

Welcome to Mama Janes Eatery, a delightful culinary spot located at 3334 Wilmington Rd, New Castle, PA. Renowned for its homestyle approach, Mama Jane's offers a menu that tempts the palate from sunrise to sunset. Start your day with their Homestyle Breakfast Menu, featuring hearty delights like Judy's Special Benedict—a delectable combination of basted eggs, avocado, bacon, and pepper jack cheese, or build your own breakfast with fluffy Belgian waffles and crispy hash browns.

As the sun sets, indulge in Down Home Dinners, showcasing juicy oven-roasted turkey and savory meatloaf. The warm, friendly atmosphere paired with generous portions ensures a communal dining experience that feels like coming home. Customers rave about the attentive service and the quality of meals, making every visit a heartfelt journey. Join us at Mama Janes Eatery, where each dish celebrates comfort and flavor, garnering a space in your heart and on your plate.

Dinner From the Water

Fish Fry

Fresh battered fish served with tartar sauce and lemon wedge.

US$18.09

Baked Fish

Your choice of garlic, cajun or lemon pepper. Add grilled shrimp for an additional charge.

US$18.09

Atlantic Salmon Fillet

Grilled Salmon Fillet with choice of seasoning.

US$19.99

Shrimp Dinner

6 butterfly breaded shrimp deep-fried golden brown served with zesty cocktail sauce and lemon wedge.

US$19.29

Oven-Roasted Turkey Dinner

Juicy slices of turkey breast served on a bed of homestyle dressing and covered in gravy.

US$19.29

Pot Roast Dinner

Slow-cooked fall apart goodness topped with sauteed mushrooms, onions and our delicious creamy gravy.

US$19.29

Chicken Tender Dinner

Savory breaded tenders served with dipping sauce. Just ask and we can spice them up for you!

US$18.79

Liver & Onions

Grilled tender beef liver smothered in sauteed onions with butter and topped with bacon.

US$18.79

Roy's Rancher

8 oz. Strip steak grilled to your liking. Add sauteed mushrooms, onions or sweet peppers for an additional charge.

US$19.99

Meatloaf Dinner

Hearty homestyle meatloaf topped with rich brown gravy.

US$18.09

Asian Vegetable Stir Fry

Choose your protein and your sauce. Accompanied with rice and oriental vegetables.

US$14.59

Down Home Dinners

Sweets & Treats

Pecan Rolls

US$4.99

Lava Cake

A la mode for an additional charge.

US$5.79

Tiramisu

US$5.99

Cinnamon Rolls

US$4.79

Mile High Apple Pie

Delicious slice of our Featured Fruit Pie of the Day! Call for availability at your local Mama Jane's. A la mode for an additional charge.

US$5.79

Coconut Cream Pie

Heavenly slice of our Featured Cream Pie of the Day! Call for availability at your local Mama Jane's.

US$5.79

Cheesecake

US$7.59

Split Grilled Cinnamon Roll Treat

Served with one scoop of vanilla ice cream and drizzled with tasty caramel sauce.

US$5.79

Charming Cherry Fruit Pie

US$5.79

Cookies

US$1.99

Angel Food Cake Delight

With your Choice of Strawberry or Blueberry Topping.

US$4.39

Decadent Double Chocolate Cake

US$5.79

Chocolate Creme Pie

US$5.79

Muffins

US$3.99

Carrot Cake

US$5.99

Pittsburgh Salad With Steak

Grilled Steak with generous portion of mixed greens, Cheddar cheese, tomato, cucumber, red pepper, and red onion rings, topped with French fries.

US$18.99

Pittsburgh Salad With Chicken

Your choice of Grilled Chicken or Crispy Chicken with generous portion of mixed greens, Cheddar cheese, tomato, cucumber, red pepper, and red onion rings, topped with French fries.

US$18.59

Side Salad

Mixed greens, tomato, onion, cucumber and croutons.

US$5.69

Grilled Salmon Salad

Grilled salmon topping off a generous portion of mixed greens, Cheddar cheese, tomato, cucumber, red pepper, and red onion rings, topped with French fries.

US$19.79

Buffalo Chicken Salad

A mixture of crisp greens and veggies with fried chicken tenders or grilled chicken diced and tossed in our special hot sauce. Topped with our crispy fries. Try me, I'm delicious.

US$18.59

Taco Salad

A golden brown tortilla shell filled with a generous amount of taco meat, mixed greens, tomatoes, onions, and Cheddar cheese. Topped with salsa and sour cream.

US$18.09

From the Garden

A La Carte Side Dishes

A La Carte Side - Baby Baked Potatoes

US$5.69

A La Carte Side - Mashed Potatoes

US$5.69

A La Carte Side - Garden Salad

US$5.69

A La Carte Side - Cottage Cheese

US$5.69

A La Carte Side - Baked Sweet Potato

US$5.69

A La Carte Side - Veggie Of The Day

US$5.69

A La Carte Side - French Fries

US$5.69

A La Carte Side - Coleslaw

US$5.69

A La Carte Side - Mac N' Cheese

US$5.69

A La Carte Side - Apple Sauce

US$5.69

A La Carte Side - Grape Salad

US$4.89

Build Your Own Omelet

3 egg omelet with your choice of 3 favorite ingredients. 1.49 each additional ingredient. Steak 2.29 additional charge.

US$17.29

Homestyle Breakfast Menu - Omelettes

Homestyle Breakfast Menu - Breakfast on the Side

Bacon

(3) three pieces of Bacon.

US$4.89

Toast

White, wheat, rye, sourdough, or grilled Texas toast.

US$4.89

Sausage Links

(3) three Sausage Links.

US$4.89

Canadian Bacon

(2) Slices of Canadian Bacon.

US$4.89

Grape Salad

US$4.89

Fried Breakfast Potatoes

US$4.89

Mama Jane's Fresh Baked Muffin

Your choice of Blueberry or Banana Nut. Try it grilled!

US$3.99

Hash Browns

US$4.89

Sausage Patties

(2) two Sausage Patties.

US$4.89

Oatmeal

US$4.89

English Muffin

US$4.89

Corned Beef Hash

US$5.99

Patty Melt

Our seasoned beef patty smothered with sauteed onions on grilled rye with American cheese. A favorite. Soup choices vary at each location, please call for exact soups if needed.

US$16.89

Chicken Tender Melt

Golden fried chicken tenders, bacon, and pepper jack cheese on grilled sourdough with a side of ranch for dipping. Soup choices vary at each location, please call for exact soups if needed.

US$17.29

Grilled Reuben

A delicious rye, corn beef, kraut, and Swiss with thousand island dressing. A grilled favorite. Soup choices vary at each location, please call for exact soups if needed.

US$14.89

Turkey Melt

Fresh baked turkey loaded with bacon and American cheese on grilled sourdough bread. Soup choices vary at each location, please call for exact soups if needed.

US$16.89

Melts

Homestyle Breakfast Menu - Traditional Breakfast

Steak & Eggs

8 oz. Strip Steak served with 2 eggs prepared any style* . With Your Choice of - 1.) either 2 Pancakes, 2 Slices of French Toast, Toast or Fresh Baked Muffin 2.) either Hashbrowns or Breakfast Potatoes *Notice: eggs served over easy, basted, poached, sunny-side up or soft boiled and hamburgers and steaks that are served rare or medium rare may be undercooked and will only be served upon the consumer's request if permitted by Health Department regulations. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase the risk of foodborne illness.

US$19.99

Build Your Own Breakfast

2 eggs* any style. With your choice of - 1.) either 3 sausage links, 2 sausage patties or 3 strips of bacon 2.) either 2 pancakes, 2 Slices of French Toast, Toast or Fresh Baked Muffin 3.) either Hash Browns, Breakfast Potatoes or Grape Salad *Notice: eggs served over easy, basted, poached, sunny-side up or soft boiled and hamburgers and steaks that are served rare or medium rare may be undercooked and will only be served upon the consumer's request if permitted by Health Department regulations. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase the risk of foodborne illness.

US$17.59

Belgium Waffle

One large fluffy waffle served with maple syrup. Add Strawberry or Blueberry Topping for an additional charge

US$12.59

3 Pancakes

3 Fluffy Buttermilk Pancakes. Served with maple syrup or available with fruit topping for an extra charge.

US$12.59

Homestyle Breakfast Menu - Build Your Own Breakfast

Homestyle Breakfast Menu - Biscuits, Benedicts, & Beyond

Judy's Special Benedict

2 Basted eggs* served with diced avocados, bacon strips, pepper jack cheese, and tomatoes, topped with garlic seasoning. Your Choice of Potato. A special treat just for you! *Notice: eggs served over easy, basted, poached, sunny-side up or soft boiled and hamburgers and steaks that are served rare or medium rare may be undercooked and will only be served upon the consumer's request if permitted by health department regulations. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase the risk of foodborne illness.

US$17.39

Jane's Mini Breakfast

Served with a choice of 2 pancakes or toast, 2 strips of bacon or sausage links, one egg cooked any style* and a potato choice. *Notice: eggs served over easy, basted, poached, sunny-side up or soft boiled and hamburgers and steaks that are served rare or medium rare may be undercooked and will only be served upon the consumer's request if permitted by Health Department regulations. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase the risk of foodborne illness.

US$13.79

Dar's Benedict

2 basted eggs* with grilled Canadian bacon and a creamy Hollandaise sauce on top of a grilled English muffin. Served with potato choice. *Notice: eggs served over easy, basted, poached, sunny-side up or soft boiled and hamburgers and steaks that are served rare or medium rare may be undercooked and will only be served upon the consumer's request if permitted by health department regulations. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase the risk of foodborne illness.

US$17.39

Stuffed Biscuit Platter

2 homestyle biscuits stuffed with choice of chicken or sausage, smothered with our rich cream gravy, 2 eggs any style* and a potato choice. *Notice: eggs served over easy, basted, poached, sunny-side up or soft boiled and hamburgers and steaks that are served rare or medium rare may be undercooked and will only be served upon the consumer's request if permitted by Health Department regulations. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase the risk of foodborne illness.

US$17.39

Chicken Parmesan Dinner

A delightful dish, breaded chicken served on a bed of spaghetti and topped with sauce and provolone cheese. Served with Garlic Toast.

US$17.59

Spaghetti With Meatballs

Classic Italian Favorite. Spaghetti noodles served with home-made marinara sauce and 2 large meatballs.

US$15.29

Pasta Alfredo

Linguine combined with a creamy Alfredo sauce and broccoli. Served with Garlic Toast.

US$13.99

Shrimp Pasta Alfredo

Linguine combined with a creamy alfredo sauce topped with broccoli and shrimp.

US$18.99

Chicken Pasta Alfredo

Linguine combined with a creamy Alfredo sauce topped with broccoli and chicken. Served with Garlic Toast.

US$18.79

Pasta

Appetizers & Small Plates

Cheese Quesadilla

Add chicken for an additional charge.

US$11.29

Pizza Logs

4 crispy wonton logs filled with mozzarella cheese and pepperoni. Fried to a golden brown and served with our homemade marinara sauce.

US$12.59

Mozzarella Sticks

6 battered, deep-fried golden with marinara sauce.

US$10.79

Pretzels

3 Large deep fried pretzel sticks served with creamy cheese sauce.

US$11.89

Build Your Own Appetizer Platter

Choose 4 of your favorites: 2 tenders, 6 Fried Mushrooms, 2 cheese sticks, 2 pizza logs, 1 jumbo pretzel stick, or French fries. Deep-fried to perfection.

US$15.79

Fried Mushrooms

One dozen lightly breaded Button Mushrooms deep fried golden brown and served with our delicious Ranch dressing.

US$10.79

Chicken Tenders

All white meat breaded tenders served with dipping sauce.

US$13.19

Hot Drinks

US$3.29

Soft Drink - Pepsi Products

The bold, refreshing, robust cola

US$3.69

Milk

US$3.79

Fresh Brewed Iced Tea

US$3.69

Juices

US$3.89

Beverages

Sandwiches

Turkey BLT

Our BLT loaded with bacon and served on toasted bread.

US$15.69

Old Fashioned Hot Sandwiches

Choice of pot roast, turkey, or meatloaf tucked between 2 slices of bread, smothered with gravy. A delight!

US$17.59

Burgers & Chicken

Your choice of our veggie patty or seasoned beef patty or grilled chicken breast or fried chicken patty. Choose your bun, wheat bun or brioche bun. Served with cheese, topped with lettuce, sliced tomato and onion. Soup choices vary at each location, please call for exact soups if needed.

US$16.89

BLT

An oldie but goodie! Crispy bacon slices topped with lettuce and tomato on Sourdough toast.

US$15.69

Fish Sandwich

Fresh battered fish on a grilled hoagie bun with lettuce, cheese, and tartar sauce on the side.

US$16.29

The Philly Steak

Flavorful roast beef with a medley of peppers and onions, topped with melted provolone cheese on a grilled hoagie roll.

US$14.99

Soup - Cup Or Bowl

Choose between our daily homestyle cream soup or Soup of the Day. Daily Soup choice varies at each location. Please call for selection of the day.

US$4.79

Soup In A Bread Bowl

Enjoy a delicious bowl of our homemade soup in a fresh baked bread bowl seasoned to perfection. Choose between our daily homestyle cream soup or Soup of the Day. Daily Soup choice varies at each location. Please call for selection of the day if needed. Bread Bowl will be packaged separately.

US$8.99

Soups